Unreasonable Demands in Insurance Bad Faith

Insurance is supposed to provide peace when the unexpected happens, but what if the help you’re promised comes with endless struggles? Many policyholders turn to their insurer for support, only to face requests and requirements that seem excessive, irrelevant, or impossible to meet.

That’s why it’s important to understand what insurance bad faith, unreasonable demands, and poor insurance support look like. This article breaks down the most common types of unreasonable demands and how a skilled Texas insurance lawyer can help protect your rights.

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance companies are required to process claims fairly and within the law.
  • Unreasonable demands from an insurer may indicate insurance bad faith.
  • Policyholders should challenge excessive or unnecessary requests for information from their insurance company.
  • A Texas insurance lawyer can help you stand up for your rights and secure whatever fair treatment and compensation you’re owed.

Types of Unreasonable Insurance Demands

Filing an insurance claim is stressful enough, especially when you're injured, out of work, or recovering from loss. But it gets worse when your insurance company doesn’t play fair. Rather than honoring your policy in good faith, they may throw up roadblocks disguised as routine requests. 

These roadblocks are often signs of insurance bad faith or claim denials, and you don’t have to put up with them. Some common types of unreasonable demands from insurers include:

  • Requesting Proof Before Investigating — Insurers may demand detailed documentation of your losses before initiating their investigation. This puts the burden on you unfairly and is often a tactic to delay or dismiss your claim.
  • Asking for Irrelevant or Unrelated Evidence — You might be asked to provide receipts or medical records that have nothing to do with your specific policy or incident. These requests waste time and confuse the real issue.
  • Demanding Medical Records Before They’re Finalized — Some injuries take time to fully manifest. Still, insurers may pressure you to submit incomplete or premature records, potentially undervaluing the seriousness of your condition.
  • Repeatedly Asking for the Same Information — If your insurer keeps requesting the same documents you’ve already sent, it could be an attempt to wear you down.
  • Rejecting Valid Documents Without Real Reason — If your paperwork is consistently denied for vague or shifting reasons, it’s time to question whether the insurer is acting in bad faith.

When faced with tactics like these, don’t go at it alone. A bad faith insurance attorney, like those at Millin and Millin Attorneys, can help you recognize these bad faith practices and hold your insurer accountable. You paid for coverage, don’t let unreasonable demands stand in your way.

What to Do If Your Insurance Company Acts in Bad Faith

When you’ve paid your premiums and trusted your insurer to show up when it matters most, bad faith treatment feels like betrayal. Recognizing the signs of insurance bad faith is the first step in defending your rights. If your insurance company crosses the line, here’s what you should do:

1. Review Your Policy Thoroughly — Understand exactly what your coverage includes and compare it to the insurer’s actions. This can help you spot violations or misrepresentations.

2. Document Everything — Keep detailed records of emails, phone calls, denial letters, and requests for documents. Bad faith cases often hinge on showing a pattern of misconduct.

3. Speak to a Texas Insurance Lawyer — Bad faith insurance claims can be complex, and insurers often have huge legal teams. An experienced attorney like those at Millin and Millin Attorneys can assess your case, explain your options, and help you push back.

4. Confront the Insurer in Writing — Raise your concerns with the insurance adjuster directly. A written complaint can trigger internal reviews and formal responses.

5. File a Complaint — If the issue continues, you can file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance while preparing for further legal action.

No one should have to fight for the protection they’ve already paid for. If your insurer is acting in bad faith, you deserve strong legal support and a path toward the compensation you’re owed. 

Do You Need a Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer?

When your insurance company denies a valid claim or stalls with unreasonable demands, these tactics can leave you financially vulnerable and emotionally drained. A professional Texas insurance lawyer can help you recognize and prove bad faith behavior and take swift action.

At Millin and Millin Attorneys, we know how to challenge insurers and fight for whatever compensation you may deserve. Our team can evaluate your case, gather evidence, and work to recover what you may be owed. This might include policy benefits, financial losses, and emotional damages. In serious cases, we may pursue punitive damages to hold the insurer fully accountable.

Speak with a Skilled Texas Insurance Lawyer to Protect Your Rights

Facing unreasonable demands from your insurer can be frustrating. Knowing what constitutes bad faith and how to identify these tactics can help protect your claim. At Millin and Millin Attorneys, we stand up to insurance companies that delay or deny rightful payments.

If you’ve faced excessive requests, stalling tactics, or unfair treatment, you don’t have to deal with it alone. Our skilled Texas insurance lawyers will review your case and fight for whatever benefits you may be owed. Contact us today for a free consultation.

If your insurer acted in bad faith and denied your coverage, contact Millin and Millin Attorneys today to protect your rights.

Contact Us Today

 

WHAT CLIENTS ARE SAYING

  • John and his team did a great job for us! Tried on my own to get the insurance company to do right by us after storm damage to our roof, but they would not cooperate. Millin and Millin helped us get what we deserved.
    Kevin Pagan

  • We have worked closely with Millin & Millin twice on weather related insurance claims and both times we were so grateful for their expertise in guiding us through the process. Our experience with Millin&Millin can only be described as excellent.
    Chris Henderson

  • We cannot recommend Millin & Millin attorneys highly enough for anyone facing challenges with their insurance claims. Their efficient and effective approach, combined with their professionalism and expertise, truly sets them apart in the legal field. Thank you Millin & Millin, for your exceptional service and support and retrieving the appropriate amount from the insurance companies to fix the damages to our home.
    Chris & Vanessa Curl

  • I had a dispute with my landlord about water and mold damage in my apartment. Millin and Millin worked with me diligently to reach a desirable conclusion. They thoroughly explain all legal documentation and advise you at every step of your legal process. Their expertise and knowledge is excellent, and they will fight for you until you get the outcome you deserve.
    Caroline Harms

View More Testimonials

Request your Free Consultation

Reach out online to request an appointment with our team here at Millin & Millin Attorneys. We offer a FREE initial consultation.

Name(Required)
Please let us know what's on your mind. Have a question for us? Ask away.
Opt-in
Copyright © Millin & Millin Attorneys. All rights Reserved | Powered by Cobalt Digital
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram